Carolina Arts logo

Feature Articles

October 2011

NC Museum of Art in Raleigh, NC, Presents Largest Collection of Authentic Rembrandts for US Audience

The NC Museum of Art in Raleigh, NC, will present the exhibit, Rembrandt in America, featuring more than 30 paintings by Rembrandt and explores the intriguing and often controversial history of collecting Rembrandt paintings in America. The exhibit begins on Oct. 30, 2011 and continues through Jan. 22, 2012.

This groundbreaking new exhibition brings together the largest number of authentic Rembrandt paintings from American collections ever before assembled. Organized and presented by the North Carolina Museum of Art, the Cleveland Museum of Art, and the Minneapolis Institute of Arts, Rembrandt in America is the first major exhibition to explore how the desire for Rembrandt paintings by American collectors in turn fueled critical connoisseurship and research about the artist’s work.

The exhibition will present more than 30 autograph paintings by the Dutch master on loan from private collections and more than two dozen American art museums. It includes some of his finest masterpieces from the National Gallery of Art in Washington, DC, the Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York, the Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco and the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston.

“This exhibition is a visual treat of some of Rembrandt’s finest paintings now residing in American collections. The show also offers a rare opportunity for visitors to follow the evolving opinions of scholars regarding what makes for an authentic painting by Rembrandt,” said Dennis P. Weller, curator of Northern European Art at the North Carolina Museum of Art.

The history of Rembrandt collecting in the United States began in the late 19th century, when wealthy American Industrialists cultivated a passion for collecting European Old Masters, especially Dutch. America’s greatest Industrialists, such as J. Paul Getty, Andrew Mellon and George Eastman, desired these works of art as trophies for their collections, and so a collecting frenzy erupted and paintings by Rembrandt left Europe in substantial numbers for America.

In this highly competitive and lucrative market many of the pictures that came to America were misattributed to Rembrandt by scholars and art dealers. In many respects, America became the proving ground for new Rembrandt discoveries and reattributions.

Rembrandt in America includes works such as the recently-cleaned, matching portraits of the Rev. Johannes Elison and his wife, Maria Bockenolle, from the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston. Painted in 1634 during Rembrandt’s early years as a successful portrait painter in Amsterdam, they are the only full-length portraits by Rembrandt residing in the United States.

Other highlights of the exhibition include Rembrandt’s moving depiction of the Roman heroine, Lucretia (1666), from the collection of the Minneapolis Institute of Arts; Joris de Cauerii (1632), a portrait of a gentleman, which displays Rembrandt’s masterful handling of light and texture from the Fine Arts Museums of San Francisco; and Young Man in a Black Beret (1666), from the Nelson-Atkins Museum of Art in Kansas City, a superb example of the artist’s expressive style.

By highlighting a number of works misattributed to Rembrandt, as well as a handful of paintings for which scholarly opinion has wavered over the years, this exhibition empowers viewers to develop their own skills in connoisseurship. Furthermore, Rembrandt in America occurs at a time when a heightened scrutiny of Rembrandt authenticity continues to impact the discipline and significantly affect the art market.

“Rembrandt collecting has always been a challenging field and questions of authenticity have plagued Rembrandts for centuries, even during the artist’s own lifetime,” said Jon L. Seydl, the Paul J. and Edith Ingalls Vignos, Jr. Curator of European Paintings and Sculpture (1500-1800) at the Cleveland Museum of Art. “American audiences will now enjoy not only the opportunity to surround themselves with so many of Rembrandt’s works but also the chance to explore why some works attributed to him have been reconsidered.”

Each venue will display 15 to 20 other Dutch paintings that were previously attributed to Rembrandt at some point during their history in American collections, but have since been ascribed to his pupils and contemporaries. These include paintings by Jan Lievens and Govaert Flinck, among others.

In the exhibition, The Feast of Esther (circa 1625) and Young Man with a Sword (c. 1633-1645) from the North Carolina Museum of Art are two such paintings formerly attributed to Rembrandt that are now assigned to other artists. In the 1950s the North Carolina Museum of Art’s first director and Rembrandt expert William Valentiner recommended the acquisition of both paintings as Rembrandts. Valentiner was responsible for greatly expanding the Rembrandt oeuvre. For much of the last fifty years, many of his attributions have been questioned by other scholars, notably the Rembrandt Research Project.

The Feast of Esther is now assigned to the hand of Jan Lievens, Rembrandt’s younger colleague. The painting shares many similarities with other examples from Lievens’ oeuvre and has a grandeur of invention and boldness that Rembrandt did not achieve. Young Man with a Sword has since been identified as a product of the Rembrandt School. The imagery and stylistic elements, such as the weakness in the structure of the shoulders and face, indicate that the work is not by Rembrandt himself, while the dramatic chiaroscuro and romantic costume point to a competent painter well versed in Rembrandt’s artistic interests.

One of the most important painters in the history of European art, Rembrandt van Rijn (1606-1669) is renowned for his uncanny ability to depict light and shadow, to capture the emotions of his sitters and to intimately share historical and religious stories. He was born in 1606 in Leiden, in the Dutch Republic, now The Netherlands, and spent most of his career in Amsterdam.

While the primary focus of the exhibition is on the history of Rembrandt collecting and connoisseurship as it relates to his works residing in America, the show also explores his work across various genres, his artistic evolution, and his influence on other artists of the day. Included in this exhibition are a number of important portraits from Rembrandt’s prosperous early career in Amsterdam as the city’s most sought-after portrait painter, as well as character studies, historical and biblical scenes, and three of his celebrated self-portraits.

“Rembrandt’s development as a painter, from brash young artist to confident master to resolute observer of timeless humanity, is well documented in this exhibition with works spanning nearly the full extent of his remarkable career,” said Thomas E. Rassieur, curator of prints and drawings at the Minneapolis Institute of Arts.

Rembrandt in America is accompanied by a 240-page catalog authored by Dennis P. Weller, Thomas E. Rassieur and George Keyes, former chief curator at the Detroit Institute of Arts. An introduction focusing on Rembrandt as a cultural phenomenon is followed by essays devoted to his life, the controversies associated with his workshop, and the pursuit of Rembrandt in America. Published by Skira Rizzoli, the catalog contains 150 color illustrations and is available in hardback and paperback.

After its run in Raleigh, the exhibit will travel to the Cleveland Museum of Art where it will be on view from Feb. 19 through May 28, 2012, and then the Minneapolis Institute of Arts from June 24 through Sept. 16, 2012.

Tickets for this special exhibition are: $18 Adults, $15 Seniors, Students 13+, groups of 10 or more, $12 Children 7-12, and free for children 6 and under. Purchase timed tickets online at (, by phone at 919/715-5923, or in person at the Museum Box Office.

The North Carolina Museum of Art’s permanent collection spans more than 5,000 years, from ancient Egypt to the present, making the institution one of the premier art museums in the Southeast. The Museum’s collection provides educational, aesthetic, intellectual, and cultural experiences for the citizens of North Carolina and beyond. The 164-acre Museum Park showcases the connection between art and nature through site-specific works of environmental art. The Museum offers changing national touring exhibitions, classes, lectures, family activities, films, and concerts.

For further information check our NC Institutional Gallery listings, call the Museum at 919/839-6262 or visit (


[ | October 2011 | Feature Articles | Carolina Arts Unleashed | Gallery Listings | Home | ]



Carolina Arts is published monthly by Shoestring Publishing Company, a subsidiary of PSMG, Inc. Copyright© 2011 by PSMG, Inc., which published Charleston Arts from July 1987 - Dec. 1994 and South Carolina Arts from Jan. 1995 - Dec. 1996. It also publishes Carolina Arts Online, Copyright© 2011 by PSMG, Inc. All rights reserved by PSMG, Inc. or by the authors of articles. Reproduction or use without written permission is strictly prohibited. Carolina Arts is available throughout North & South Carolina.